Ships from South Carolina
Fit Finder › Every pistol, A to Z
Holsters for your Smith & Wesson 686 L Medium Frame
Your setup
All results below are based on this configuration.
No brand lists a fit for that light and optic together. Try another combination, or ask the Fit Finder.
Choose what to view
Pick a tab: what we have on the shelf now, or every holster that fits your setup.
Narrow your search
Every holster that fits your setup
From the makers' published fit charts, including models we do not have in stock.
Safariland2 holstersConfirmed by SafarilandView holsters
60046004-21
Tactical
SLS Tactical Holster
62806280-21
Duty · Level II retention
SLS Mid-Ride Duty Holster, Level II Retention
62826282-21Discontinued
Duty · Level II retention
SLS Hi-Ride Duty Holster, Level II Retention
Nothing matches these filters.
Bianchi6 holstersConfirmed by BianchiView holsters
5
Black Widow · Leather Concealment/Cowboy
5BHL
Thumbsnap · Leather Concealment/Cowboy, Leather Sportsman
6
Enhanced Waistband Tuckable Holster · Leather Concealment/Cowboy
7
Shadow II · Leather Concealment/Cowboy
111
Cyclone · Leather Concealment/Cowboy, Leather Sportsman
4620Discontinued
AccuMold Concealment
7000Discontinued
Sporting Holster · AccuMold Sportsman
7001Discontinued
Thumbsnap Holster · AccuMold Sportsman
7105Discontinued
Cruiser Duty Holster · AccuMold Elite / AccuMold Duty
7500Discontinued
Thumbsnap Paddle Holster · AccuMold Concealment
7506Discontinued
AccuMold Concealment
UM84RDiscontinued
Military/Tactical
X15
Shoulder Holster · Leather Concealment/Cowboy, Leather Sportsman
Nothing matches these filters.
Listed fits come from each brand's own published fit charts and order guides; Chicks Open Carry cross-fits are guns we tested in our shop. Safariland, Bianchi and Blackhawk are their owners' trademarks; Chicks Open Carry is not affiliated with them. Not sure? Try the Fit Finder.
What the fit badges mean
- Confirmed by the brand
- Listed in the brand's official fit guide.
- Confirmed by Chicks Open Carry
- Tested by Chicks Open Carry for fit and proper retention, in the exact setup shown — generation, light and optic. Not listed by the brand.